Imagine you’re lending on a 40-unit multifamily property that is fully leased, in excellent condition, with no apparent environmental red flags. Underwriting proceeds without a hitch, the loan is securitized, and three months later, the building is destroyed by fire. When it’s time to rebuild, the owner discovers that the current zoning ordinance allows only 20 units at this location. If rebuilding is restricted to 20 units, the property’s income will be reduced by half. Without a zoning report, this risk might go unnoticed until it's too late.

In the high-stakes world of Commercial Mortgage-Backed Securities (CMBS), due diligence is everything—especially in this uncertain market. A recent Trepp Report stated that In May, the CMBS delinquency rate rose to 7.08%, with the special servicing rate hitting 10.30%. Environmental reports, appraisals, and financial underwriting typically receive the spotlight—but there’s one element quietly working behind the scenes that can make or break a loan: the zoning report.

As a due diligence partner to some of the nation’s top CMBS lenders, we’ve seen firsthand how zoning compliance can directly impact collateral value, legal enforceability, and ultimately, investor confidence. The data from a zoning report informs underwriting/risk assessment and can also provide insight for special servicers in a distress scenario. Here's why this unassuming report should never be treated as a formality.

What Is a Zoning Report—And Why Does It Matter?

A zoning report is a third-party analysis that verifies whether a commercial property complies with local zoning ordinances. It covers essential legal parameters such as:

  • Zoning classification (e.g., C-2, M-1, R-4)
  • Permitted uses under the current zoning code
  • Legal conforming vs. legal non-conforming status
  • Setback, height, and parking requirements
  • Notices of zoning code violations or unresolved permits

For lenders, this information forms a legal baseline for assessing the viability of the property’s current and future use.

Here are four key reasons why zoning reports matter in CMBS deals:

Protecting the Collateral. A loan is only as secure as its underlying asset. If a property’s use is non-compliant or only conditionally permitted, the borrower may face operational restrictions, fines, or forced conversion to a lower-value use. That’s a direct hit to cash flow and property value.

Supporting Loan Structure and Risk Pricing. Properties that are "legal non-conforming" (grandfathered under prior zoning laws) may introduce long-term risk. For example, if such a property is destroyed and local codes don’t allow rebuilding to prior density, the lender could face a significant loss. Zoning reports help CMBS lenders structure covenants, insurance requirements, and even price risk accordingly.

Enabling Accurate Rating Agency Review. Rating agencies perform detailed loan-level analysis. Properties with unresolved zoning issues—or lacking sufficient zoning documentation—may be flagged or excluded from securitized pools. That’s not just an underwriting problem—it’s a securitization problem.

Enhancing Recovery Prospects in Default. In a foreclosure scenario, marketability hinges on whether the asset can continue its current use or be rebuilt similarly. A conforming zoning status supports resale value and mitigates loss exposure.

Zoning Reports vs. Zoning Endorsements

It’s important to distinguish between a zoning report and a zoning endorsement (such as ALTA 3.0 or 3.1):

  • Zoning Report: Provides a comprehensive review of local zoning codes and compliance status.
  • Zoning Endorsement: Part of a title insurance policy that provides limited assurances related to zoning, often restricted to the current use and physical attributes (e.g., height, setbacks).

One does not replace the other. A robust due diligence process should require both.

Best Practices for CMBS Lenders

At Partner, we recommend the following approach to zoning risk:

  • Always obtain a current zoning report, particularly for income-producing properties and mixed-use assets.
  • Scrutinize legal non-conforming uses for rebuilding risk and operating restrictions.
  • Ensure alignment between the zoning report, survey, and title policy.
  • Require zoning endorsements, but never use them as a substitute for full compliance verification.

The Hidden Pillar of Loan Quality

Zoning may not dominate headlines in CMBS transactions, but it underpins the legal use, income potential, and market value of every commercial asset. Ignoring it can introduce unnecessary risk into an already complex transaction structure. Lenders who treat zoning reports as essential, not optional, are better positioned to protect collateral and preserve deal integrity.

Discover more about zoning reports in this complimentary on-demand webinar, “Zoning Reports 101- Latest in Zoning Research Best Practices”, a comprehensive 60-minute course presented by Partner Engineering and Science, Inc., where you can earn 1 continuing legal education (CLE) credit approved for California, Florida and as an out-of-state course for New York. Zoning due diligence is essential in every commercial real estate transaction. By the end of this session, you’ll have a deeper understanding of how to leverage zoning reports to enhance your investment strategy, mitigate risks, and make informed decisions.

NOT FOR REPRINT

© Touchpoint Markets, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to asset-and-logo-licensing@alm.com. For more inforrmation visit Asset & Logo Licensing.