Since the Federal Reserve launched its interest rate hike campaign in mid-2022, the U.S. commercial real estate sector has undergone what experts now describe as a generational reset. Cushman & Wakefield Senior Economist Adrian Ponsen notes that industry benchmark indices reveal that CRE values have dropped anywhere from 13% to 21% from their mid-2022 peak—a decline rivaled only twice in the past forty years: during the early 1990s and the financial crisis of 2008–2009. For a sector historically prized for its resilience and stability, these figures highlight the extraordinary gravity of the downturn.
Despite the magnitude of the correction, the present market environment offers opportunity and reason for cautious optimism. CRE mortgage loans, for example, are being underwritten with conservative loan-to-value ratios averaging around 60%, a strategy providing lenders substantial protection against further price erosion and potential losses, explains Ponsen. This approach is a direct response to market volatility and signals that risk aversion—fueled by recent economic disruptions and tighter monetary policy—has become paramount among lenders. “In periods of disruption like this, protection against downside risk is really the key priority for most lenders,” said Ponsen.
Yet even with dramatic shifts in trade policy and economic uncertainty persisting throughout 2025, lenders have been lining up to finance core properties. Interest rate spreads remain tight, among the most competitive the market has seen in two decades, underscoring both lender confidence and competition.
The implications for borrowers and investors are significant. The sustained willingness of banks and private lenders to supply liquidity, even as traditional sources retrench, demonstrates a robust appetite for deals involving quality assets. Lending activity has surged in 2025: CBRE’s Lending Momentum Index soared 13% quarter-over-quarter and 90% year-over-year in the first quarter, driven by stabilizing interest rates and expanding financing volumes from banks and alternative lending sources such as life companies and debt funds. Investor demand for CRE debt is compressing cap rates, prompting a gradual recovery in property values that began at the start of 2024.
Moreover, this cycle is marked by disciplined supply-side insulation. Construction starts in the multifamily and industrial sectors have fallen by more than 60% from their peaks, a response to both elevated costs and reduced appetite for speculative development. In many cases, assets are now trading below replacement cost, particularly in the multifamily sector, setting the stage for future rent and value growth as supply shortages emerge.
As the U.S. commercial property market transitions into its next phase, the lessons of past downturns linger and inform strategy. Historically, “generational resets” have paved the way for extended periods of price appreciation and income growth, particularly for institutional investors who act decisively during the early stages of recovery.
© Arc, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to TMSalesOperations@arc-network.com. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.