Depreciation recapture, long regarded as a niche concern in commercial real estate, is emerging as a major factor in distressed asset workouts following passage of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act. As office delinquencies rise and investors evaluate exits from underwater assets, industry leaders are urging sponsors and C-suite executives to give fresh scrutiny to the way accumulated depreciation can turn an apparent loss on paper into a significant federal tax bill at foreclosure or sale.
The podcast team at Trepp, which includes Chief Product Officer Lonnie Hendry and Research Director Steven Buschbom, devoted significant attention in their latest episode to outlining the recapture dilemma. The passage of the bill makes this even more pressing by expanding bonus depreciation for property placed in service after January 19, 2025, a change that was celebrated as a windfall for sponsors hoping to juice early returns. Now, however, that provision is amplifying tax exposure when properties default or are surrendered to lenders.
Buschbom explained the mechanism. “If the borrower defaults and puts the loan back to the lender, that effectively looks like a sale on paper. So the gain recognized on foreclosure would be the outstanding loan minus the depreciated basis.” He illustrated this with a scenario: an owner acquires a property at a $10 million basis and takes $3 million in cumulative depreciation, leaving an adjusted basis of $7 million.
If, after a cash-out refinance, the property has a $12 million outstanding loan balance, a default and deed-in-lieu transfer would be treated as a $12 million sale. The taxable gain, in this case, becomes $5 million—the difference between the outstanding loan and the depreciated basis. Of that, $3 million is taxed as depreciation recapture at a 25% federal rate and the remaining $2 million as a capital gain, typically at 20%.
That distinction is crucial. “Accelerated depreciation, which got a boost from the big beautiful bill, would lower your basis even more, meaning the taxable gain on foreclosure could be much higher,” Buschbom said. This means that owners inclined to “hand back the keys” as a way out of rising distress are seeing new reasons to hesitate. A paper loss does not guarantee a tax loss, and for sponsors who used every available tool—cost segregation, bonus depreciation and short holding periods—the recapture tax can quickly reach seven figures.
“It’s a very, very large federal tax bill,” as Bushbaum put it.
Hendry added context for asset managers. “This is the part the Instagram gurus and cost segregation evangelists don’t talk about,” he said.
“These strategies work great if you’re a long-term holder, or you’re buying, holding, refinancing and passing the property on to heirs. But for transactional investors, especially those facing default, the tax consequences can be severe.”
The new legislation makes it even easier to front-load depreciation but forces sponsors to confront a correspondingly larger payback if things go sideways.
The result is a new set of decision points for executives: Does it make sense to inject more capital into a troubled asset to avoid a foregone gain and an immediate tax bill? Or is it better to walk, facing the IRS as well as the lender? According to the Trepp discussion, careful modeling is required. Hendry underscored the need for “a good framework” that integrates recapture risk into every disposition model and workout analysis.
Both analysts called for greater sophistication in asset management playbooks. “There’s more that needs to be explained,” Buschbom said. “Everyone sees the dollar signs and the benefit on today’s taxes. They don’t necessarily see what happens when the recapture comes in.”
For sponsors and investors, especially under the latest accelerated depreciation rules, working closely with tax counsel and servicers before pursuing any form of strategic default is now essential. The new calculus, shaped by the big beautiful bill, is clear: rapid write-offs today create real liabilities tomorrow—even for those losing the keys to distressed real estate.
© Arc, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to TMSalesOperations@arc-network.com. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.