Fears that generative artificial intelligence will wipe out millions of white‑collar jobs—and the demand for office space along with them—may be premature. According to a new Vanguard report, the current wave of AI adoption appears to be reshaping work rather than destroying it.
In its study, Vanguard argues that while AI tools have started to alter workflows, “its role in explaining the recent slowdown in job growth is overstated.” The analysis suggests that instead of fueling broad layoffs, generative AI is helping workers become more productive by shifting routine work toward higher‑value tasks.
Vanguard found that roughly 100 occupations most exposed to AI automation have actually outperformed the broader labor market in both job growth and real wage gains. That finding supports the firm’s conclusion that the technology so far is more of an enhancer than a replacement. Still, researchers cautioned that the analysis covers a limited period, leaving open questions about longer‑term impacts.
The report also notes that AI’s early benefits are uneven. Entry‑level workers face a “disproportionate burden” in a job market where low hiring rates can stall younger employees’ careers—an issue seen even in fields largely untouched by automation. And while large language models may excel in standardized tests like coding challenges, they often falter in real‑world decision‑making that requires nuance and context.
It’s still early. The first version of ChatGPT debuted in late 2022, meaning the industry is barely three years into the generative AI era.
Early missteps underscore the volatility of this stage: a Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee minority staff report warned that AI and automation could “destroy nearly 100 million U.S. jobs in a decade,” while an MIT study found that 95% of corporate AI initiatives fail.
Even so, Vanguard’s findings suggest AI’s immediate effect leans toward augmentation, not annihilation. For commercial real estate investors, the takeaway may be patience.
© Arc, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to TMSalesOperations@arc-network.com. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.