New York City has long attracted young professionals, artists and creatives chasing opportunity and culture. But over the past two decades, the makeup of the city’s renters has shifted dramatically — and it’s getting older. According to a new report from Chandan Economics, the “greying” of Gotham is reshaping the city’s rental market and tightening access to housing.
Drawing on U.S. Census Bureau data and the Integrated Public Use Microdata Series (IPUMS), the firm found that renters under 35 made up 30.8% of the metro area’s rental households in January 2005. By January 2024, that share had dropped to 26.5%. During the same period, the number of renters aged 35 and older rose by more than 540,000 households — a 24% jump — while the under-35 group grew by fewer than 10,000, essentially flat over 20 years.
The report notes that the younger renter segment has fluctuated sharply with broader economic cycles — dropping after the 2008 financial crisis, bouncing slightly in the early 2010s and then plunging again through the pandemic as many younger residents left the city in search of space and affordability. Meanwhile, older households have continued to rent in greater numbers and for longer periods.
“Older households are remaining renters for longer, whether by necessity, preference, or delayed mobility, while younger households face greater barriers to both renting independently and transitioning into ownership,” Chandan wrote.
The result, the firm added, is structural: renting is no longer a temporary stage in New York — it’s becoming a long-term housing state for a growing share of residents.
Even as overall population growth has slowed, the city’s rental market remains tight. The issue, according to Chandan, “is no longer just how many renters there are, but who they are — and how long they stay.”
© Arc, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to TMSalesOperations@arc-network.com. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.