The balance of who moves—and who stays put—in the U.S. housing market has quietly flipped and it could reshape where developers place their next bets.
Rising mortgage rates, elevated home prices, and pandemic-driven shifts in how and where people live have combined to slow homeownership while accelerating rentership. From 2019 to 2024, renters became more mobile than homeowners in all 100 of the largest U.S. cities, according to PropertyShark. The shift marks a notable break from long-standing patterns and offers a new signal for developers tracking demand.
Before the pandemic, renters already moved more frequently than homeowners, largely because of demographics and greater flexibility. Renters tend to be younger and less tied to long-term commitments, while homeowners face transaction costs and financing hurdles that discourage frequent moves.
But the gap has widened as the economics of ownership have deteriorated. Higher mortgage rates and constrained inventory have made buying and selling more difficult, effectively locking many homeowners in place. At the same time, renters are navigating a widening gap between rental costs and ownership expenses, while benefiting in some markets from new supply that has helped stabilize prices.
The result is a measurable divergence in mobility trends across major metros. According to Property Shark, 41 of the 100 largest cities saw homeowner mobility decline even as renter mobility increased. Port St. Lucie, Florida, recorded the sharpest contrast, with owner mobility down 125 basis points and renter mobility up 861 basis points. Winston-Salem, North Carolina, Atlanta, Omaha and San Antonio showed similar patterns, though with less extreme spreads. Even at the lower end of this group, San Diego still saw homeowner mobility fall by 49 basis points while renter mobility ticked up 22 basis points.
Another 23 cities experienced rising mobility for both groups, though renters still outpaced homeowners. Greensboro, North Carolina, led this category with a 291-basis-point increase in owner mobility and an 822-basis-point jump among renters. Miami, Plano, Durham and Stockton also posted strong gains, suggesting that in some markets, broader economic or population growth is driving movement across tenure types rather than suppressing it.
Not all markets are in motion. Twenty cities saw declines in mobility for both homeowners and renters, suggesting localized constraints or a cooling of demand. Chandler, Arizona, posted the steepest drop in homeowner mobility at 746 basis points, while Lubbock, Aurora, St. Paul and Colorado Springs also recorded declines across both groups.
In some cases, structural factors are amplifying the slowdown among homeowners. Newark, New Jersey, saw the largest drop in owner mobility at 297 basis points, alongside a 41.4% decline in home sales turnover across the metro. Institutional buyers played a significant role in that dynamic, "further reducing opportunities for traditional buyers and limiting homeowner mobility," according to the report. A median sale price of $578,000 added another barrier to entry.
For developers and investors, the implications are straightforward but significant. Markets with rising renter mobility may signal stronger demand for flexible housing options and rental supply, particularly in areas where ownership has become less attainable. At the same time, declining homeowner mobility could constrain for-sale inventory and reshape pricing dynamics, reinforcing the affordability pressures already reshaping the housing landscape.
© Arc, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to TMSalesOperations@arc-network.com. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.