For more retail coverage, click GlobeSt.com/RETAIL.
SYDNEY-General Property Trust’s self-management proposal won out over an alternative proposal put forth by Lend Lease, which has managed the trust‘s $9 billion of shopping center and office assets since 1999. A vote for either proposal was to result in GPT being self-managed, but by approving GPT’s own plan unitholders signed off on a pair of controversial transactions that GPT claims are necessary to effect the transition and that Lend Lease claims are bad for unitholders in the long run. Back in February, GPT proposed self-management as part of a plan to counter a takeover attempt by Stockland Group. Under the proposal, now approved, GPT will sell interests in three GPT retail centers to Westfield–including Sydney’s Penrith Plaza, the third-most productive shopping center in Australia–and use the proceeds to fund a joint venture with Babcock & Brown Ltd., Australia’s second biggest publicly traded investment bank. In addition, the plan will give unitholders a 16.5% increase in distributions in 2006.Lend Lease officials ultimately spoke in favor of GPT managing itself–a change that will cost it an estimated $65 million in fees annually and more in development revenue–but spoke out against GPT’s plan, saying in public statements that it had “numerous flaws,” a position that was backed by independent third-party analysis. Lend Lease said those flaws include the sale of GPT’s prime retail assets to Westfield (a 6.5% unitholder in GPT) at “a discount to true value” and the Babcock & Brown JV, which Lend Lease believes will take GPT into new markets with “a disproportionate level of risk and lesser rewards.” “The inseparable package of deals that GPT management has tied into its proposal is, in our view, not in GPT unit holders’ interests,” Lend Lease’s Group CEO Greg Clarke was quoted as saying. GPT independent chairman Peter Joseph maintained that GPT’s proposal offers unitholders higher growth and value than the Lend Lease alternative. As an alternative, Lend Lease said publicly that if unitholders reject the GPT proposal it would support an internalization that didn’t include those transactions by providing its management services at cost–with no incentive or performance fees–until the internalization is effected. That offer is no longer on the table, but Lend Lease and GPT have reached agreement on key aspects of the transition. Key elements of the transition agreement include: