PHILADELPHIA-HSP Gaming LLP, the parent company of SugarHouse Casino, has taken legal steps to eliminate what it calls “roadblocks” to the start of construction of its $550-million casino on S. Columbus Blvd. It has filed a petition for review with the Pennsylvania Supreme Court along with an application for summary relief against the City, the City Council, and the City Planning Commission.

In the 54-page petition, HSP seeks an order requiring the three entities “to comply with their duties to implement the decision by the Pennsylvania Gaming Control Board to locate a Category 2 gaming facility” on HSP's site. It notes that the PGCB has sole jurisdiction in this matter, a condition that has been reiterated in Rendell previous court decisions and by Gov. Ed. The PGCB awarded the two licenses designated for Philadelphia to SugarHouse and Foxwoods.

HSP charges that “the City Council has continued to refuse to implement the gaming board's decision by failing to designate the approved zoning…and has defied the decision of the (PCBG), as upheld by this court.” It notes that the City Council “has thrown roadblocks in the orderly development” of gaming in the city and “intentionally delayed” the necessary approvals and permits.

In the application for summary relief, HSP calls for an expedited briefing schedule on its petition for review and asks the court to appoint a master with jurisdiction over the matter. It also calls for a writ of mandamus, which is a court mandate, or an injunction that would require the planning commission to enact bills covering the necessary approvals and permits within 10 days of a court order.

The documents cite Councilman Frank DiCicco, in whose district the casino is planned, among those stalling the effort. DiCicco was instrumental in getting a bill in the state legislature that would prohibit gaming establishments within 1,500 feet of residences. The bill awaits a vote.

There was no immediate comment from DiCicco or from Mayor John Street, who has been a proponent of casino construction. Mayor Street's term ends in January. During an October 21 debate, both Al Taubenberger and Michael Nutter, the respective Republican and Democratic mayoral candidates, said they favored the legislation.

The Philadelphia Neighborhood Alliance responded immediately to the lawsuits. In a statement, the alliance praised the City Council and DiCicco's efforts and condemned Gov. Rendell for showing “he is unwilling to stand up for the citizens of Philadelphia.”

Instant Insights /

SugarHouse Sues City Over Casino Delays

Related Stories

Recommended For You