Last Friday’s jobs report capped a week of economic data that painted a picture of an economy at a crossroads, leaving policymakers and investors alike searching for clarity on the Federal Reserve’s next moves. With numbers rolling in on manufacturing, factory orders, productivity, wages, and consumer credit, the central question remains: when, if ever, will the Fed feel confident enough to cut interest rates?
At the heart of the debate is the central bank's delicate balancing act between its dual mandates—maximum sustainable employment and price stability. If inflation heats up, the Fed is forced to tighten policy, risking slower growth and job losses. But if the job market weakens too much, the pressure mounts to loosen policy and stimulate the economy. The challenge, as always, is that the Fed can’t move in both directions at once.
The May jobs report offered little in the way of easy answers. The U.S. economy added 139,000 jobs, slightly beating expectations but down from April’s revised total of 147,000. The unemployment rate held steady at 4.2%, a level it has hovered near for over a year. Hourly wages rose 3.9% year-over-year, outpacing the 3.7% economists had forecast, while consumer credit grew at an annualized 4.3% between March and April—double the pace of the previous month, according to Federal Reserve data.
Recommended For You
Beneath the surface, however, signs of caution are mounting. Ger Doyle, regional president of North America at ManpowerGroup, described the labor market as “steady but cautious,” noting a 7% drop in open job postings and a 16% decline in new postings in May—the first full contraction of 2025 across all functions, echoing slowdowns seen in late 2024. Doyle characterized the mood as a “temporary chill,” with both employers and employees holding steady as they wait for clearer signals.
Job openings, meanwhile, rose unexpectedly to 7.4 million at the end of April, but the longer-term trend remains downward since the post-pandemic peak in March 2022. According to ADP, private-sector hiring slowed to just 37,000 jobs in May, the weakest pace in two years. Jobless claims also hit an eight-month high, though analysts caution this may be a seasonal blip rather than the start of a new trend.
On the industrial front, the picture is equally mixed. The Institute for Supply Management’s manufacturing index fell to 48.5 in May, marking a third straight month of contraction and the lowest reading since late last year.
Exports have dropped to a five-year low, imports to a 16-year low, both reflecting the disruptive effects of elevated tariffs and global trade uncertainty. The ISM services index also slipped into contraction territory at 49.9, its weakest showing since June 2024, with new orders and backlogs both hitting multi-year lows. New orders for manufactured goods fell 3.7% in April, following four consecutive months of decline. Nonfarm labor productivity dropped 1.5% in the first quarter, the first such decline since 2022, as output slipped and hours worked increased.
Against this backdrop, the bond market is flashing warning signs. The yield on the 10-year Treasury note ended last week at 4.51%, a level that suggests investors are bracing for uncertainty and possibly higher rates ahead. Short-term Treasury yields, meanwhile, have fallen as investors seek safer, shorter-term bets.
For the Federal Reserve, the path forward is anything but clear. With business activity slowing and the specter of recession looming, the risk of cutting rates too soon is that the Fed may find itself with too little ammunition if the economy takes a turn for the worse. But if inflation, fueled by tariffs and other macroeconomic pressures, rears its head again, the central bank could be forced to raise rates quickly, risking further economic pain.
Fed officials have signaled repeatedly that they need to see several more months of data—at least a full quarter—before making any decisions. Hopes for a summer rate cut have faded, with central bank policymakers making it clear they are in no rush to move. For now, uncertainty reigns, and the only certainty is that the Fed’s balancing act has rarely looked more precarious.
© Touchpoint Markets, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more inforrmation visit Asset & Logo Licensing.
