Three ranchers were looking for the line change, which wouldhave moved the line 750 feet closer to the ocean around theirranches and 750 feet further away from the ocean in along anothersection of the boundary. The ranches argued that the line – whichsits a little more eastward near the ranches than it does elsewhere- has been in the wrong place for years, restricting the area wheretheir cattle can graze. The commission voted unanimously againstthe idea.

Land east of the development line is restricted by local zoningand land-use laws. Land west of the line is considered publicdomain, which means the property owner doesn't pay taxes on it andmust obtain a special permit from the state to build on it. Thecommission received more than 300 letters against relocating theline. Most feared the change would set a dangerous precedent forother sections of coastline. Others were concerned about reducingpublic access and recreational rights.